300: RISE OF AN EMPIRE Review

     March 6, 2014

300-rise-of-an-empire-sullivan-stapleton-slice

When Zack Snyder’s 300 was released in 2007, it was a vibrant explosion of exhilarating bloodshed and goofy earnestness.  Although its impact has been somewhat diminished by imitators and a more widespread reliance on predominantly CGI environments, it’s still a memorable picture, and providing a sequel isn’t completely unwarranted.  However, 300: Rise of an Empire has trouble expanding beyond “300 with boats”, and while it’s still packed with fun kills and a similar tone, some of the key elements are missing, and all it really has to add to the mix is a delightful performance from Eva Green.

300: Rise of an Empire is a prequel, side-story, and sequel to 300.  It begins by explaining the origins of the “god king” Xerxes (Rodrigo Santoro), how his father King Darius (Igal Naor) was felled by an arrow fired by the Athenian hero Themistokles (Sullivan Stapleton), and Xerxes’ plans to take revenge on Greece with the help of his ruthless general Artemisia (Green).  Unlike the Spartans, the Athenians are skilled sailors, and most of the action takes place at sea as Themistokles and Artemisia battle across the sea, and we occasionally cut to moments from 300 to get a concept of the timeline.

300-rise-of-an-empire-23

Director Noam Murro faces two major disadvantages in his adaptation.  First, he has to follow Snyder, and 300 was his breakout film.  The original grossed over $450 million worldwide, and so it brings heavy expectations for the sequel.  But some people may not know how faithfully Snyder followed Frank Miller and Lynn Varley’s graphic novel.  Murro has no graphic novel, so he tries to follow Snyder’s example with speed ramping and loads of CGI blood.

Unfortunately, he omits other elements that gave Snyder’s film its extra pop.  While Snyder did have a blueprint, Murro doesn’t bring over the monsters or the other bizarre elements that peppered the original.  The CGI blood is also diminished because even though the kills are brutal, the blood doesn’t pop against the grey, overcast backdrop where most of the movie takes place.  It’s as if Murro is trying to create a movie that’s slightly more grounded, but he’s also obligated to play to the bombast established in the first film.

300-rise-of-an-empire-sullivan-stapleton

This ambivalence is also present in the characters of Themistokles and Artemisia.  Stapleton has the rugged, leading man looks, but he lacks Butler’s charisma and personality.  Butler made us believe that King Leonidas could command the respect of his men, and they would gladly follow him to a glorious death.  Themistokles is the responsible adult in the room.  He’s a leader because he killed Darius and tells the sailors what to do.

By comparison, Artemisia is terrifying, and Green has the screen presence to convince us that her character can force anyone into submission.  What’s more remarkable about her performance is that she never chews the scenery.  Green is clearly having a blast, but she also holds the picture’s ideal tempo—serious enough to captivate the audience, but not so po-faced as to drain out all the fun.  She also has the benefit of some gorgeous costumes, which makes her even more colorful when contrasted against the Athenians uniform blue capes.

300-rise-of-an-empire-eva-green

Pulled apart by its desire to be taken seriously and playing into the grandiosity from the original, Murro’s picture falls into a state of mediocrity.  It wants to go its own direction into a movie that’s a little more serious and substantive (at least the Athenians can honestly proclaim a love of freedom whereas it rings hollow with the Spartans, who force parents to throw weak babies off a cliff), but it’s also a movie where a guy goes into a magic pool and emerges golden, pierced, and taller.  It also sticks us with the bland Themistokles when we really want to spend more time with Artemisia.  Torn in different directions, 300: Rise of an Empire is occasionally enjoyable, but ultimately lost at sea.

Rating: C+

300-rise-of-an-empire-final-poster

Around The Web

Latest News

Director Gil Kenan Talks POLTERGEIST, Why he Made the Film, and Future Projects

Plus, Kenan talks about knowing he'd face criticism no matter how good the film ended up.

JURASSIC WORLD: New Featurette Welcomes You to the Park with Tons of New Footage

"To see 'Jurassic World' come to life is like seeing 'Jurassic Park' come true."

Cary Fukunaga Will Not Direct Stephen King’s IT for New Line

Reasons ranging from the poor box office take of 'Poltergeist' to plain old budget cuts have been cited.

3 New ANT-MAN Images Size up Paul Rudd, Michael Doulgas, and Evangeline Lilly

Marvel’s next film is less than two months away.

9 Movies You Forgot Were Scored by Hans Zimmer

One of the best composers of our time has a resume that's both extensive and versatile, ranging from 'Cool Runnings' to 'Mission: Impossible 2'.

FANTASTIC FOUR International Trailer Brings New Footage; Josh Trank Denies Reshoot Rumors

The director takes to social media to debunk troubled word on the upcoming blockbuster.

More THE MARTIAN Images Feature Matt Damon Surviving Ridley Scott’s Red Planet

The upcoming film also stars Jessica Chastain, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Kristen Wiig, and Jeff Daniels.

DHEEPAN Review | Cannes 2015

Jacques Audiard's latest film won the Palme d'Or at this year's Cannes Film Festival.

Bad Weekend: The Last 10 Memorial Day Movies, Ranked

It turns out most Memorial Day movies aren’t very good.

AMY Review | Cannes 2015

Asif Kapadia's ('Senna') documentary is a biography of sorts, but also an incredible tribute to her as an artist.

Page 1 of 3,96312345...102030...Last »