September 9, 2013


In Dante’s Inferno, the lowest circle of hell is reserved for betrayers.  Judas, Brutus, and Cassius get to spend eternity being masticated by Satan.  As to why Dante made betrayers lower than the low, he saw it as a betrayal of God.  However, I also like to read it as liars undermining the foundation of human society.  Betrayal is the greatest sin, but in Yuval Adler’s Bethlehem, it’s a misdemeanor.  The story is filled with characters backstabbing each other, but none of it carries weight because there’s almost no character development.  There’s barely enough to provide any emotion to the conflict between the main characters.  For a movie where betrayal is the thematic foundation, Adler may as well be building on sand.

The Israeli Secret Service has informants working in Bethlehem in order to monitor the activities of the various terrorist factions.  Sanfur (Shhadi Maryee) is a teenage informant working for Secret Service agent Razi (Tsahi Halevi), and the two have a long relationship to the point where Razi feels fatherly affection for Sanfur even though he’s putting the young man in harm’s way.  Sanfur is the younger brother of Razi’s target, Ibrahim, who is leading the al-Aqsa faction and has committed a terrorist attack in the middle of Jerusalem.  As the hunt to catch Ibrahim heats up, loyalties are tested not only between Razi and Sanfur, but also between Sanfur and his family, al-Aqsa and Ibrahim, and al-Aqsa and the Palestinian Provisional Authority.


Betrayal can provide rich, dramatic material, but in Adler’s hands, it’s used to desperately keep his film afloat.  The double-crosses keep things going and provide a semblance of conflict, but there’s no reason to care.  If Ibrahim’s lieutenant Badawi (Hitham Omari) learns a shocking truth, it’s hollow because his character is a shallow twerp.  Omari’s bland performance doesn’t help, but he doesn’t have much to work with.  Badawi is just part of a cold machine where treachery is commonplace.  If Adler wants to make a statement about everyone willing to sell each other out, he can, but I don’t know why he would want to.  It’s childish, and it doesn’t make sense since the characters care about feeling betrayed even if we don’t.

The focus on betrayal works best between Sanfur and Razi.  It’s a tragic relationship because it’s based in obfuscation and deception, and their organizations are rooted in vengeance disguised as justice.  Maryee and Haleyi have strong chemistry, and a father-son dynamic is good to have not only for the handler-informant relationship, but also in how Sanfur is betraying his true family.  It’s a relationship worth exploring.


Instead, Adler pushes it to the periphery, and forces us to watch crummy maneuvering between al-Aqsa, Hamas, and Palestinian government.  Far worse, the director drags the movie through an extended manhunt scene that has no momentum or action, and feels like a lo-rent Zero Dark Thirty.  I can’t figure out why Adler would waste so much time on a single scene when it does nothing to support his main characters or overall themes.

Bethlehem sets up its pieces and then has them meekly bump into each other.  Characters can scream and cry all they want, but the relationships and stakes are rarely worthy of those emotions.  A scene between Sanfur and Ibrahim could be heartbreaking, but that betrayal is off-screen, and only serves to set-up the big, empty set piece.  That excruciatingly dull scene not only drags down the movie, but also highlights the shallowness of everything else because those aspects apparently aren’t as worthy of Adler’s attention.  A father and son planning to betray each other as a matter of life-and-death is a conflict of biblical proportions, but in Bethlehem it may as well be in a pamphlet.

Rating: C-

For all of our TIFF 2013 coverage, click here.  Here are links to all of my TIFF 2013 reviews:

Around The Web

Latest News

Zack Snyder Defends MAN OF STEEL Ending; Teases Batman Connection and Brainiac

Ben Affleck reveals how the Metropolis destruction affected Bruce Wayne.

Friday Box Office: Holdovers Still in Charge as TERMINATOR GENISYS and MAGIC MIKE XXL Stumble into Holiday Frame

Despite solid Wednesday starts, this weekend’s two new releases will not overtake 'Inside Out’ and ‘Jurassic World’ over the July Fourth weekend.

Kevin Spacey & Adrien Brody Talk Directors, Collaboration at Jameson First Shot

The short film competition this weekend announced its three winners: Stephan Tempier, Mark Middlewick & Travis Calvert

Our Favorite “AMERICAN” Movies

With “American” in the title, it can’t be bad.

BLACK PANTHER: Ava DuVernay Passes on Directing the Marvel Film

The 'Selma' filmmaker says she and Marvel had different ideas about what a 'Black Panther' movie should be.

High-Res Presentation Reel Reveals the JOHN CARTER that Could Have Been

This actually looks awesome.

BATMAN V SUPERMAN Scenes Include a Rainy Rooftop Battle and Solemn Chats with Alfred

Get ready for some more crash-bang destruction, now with twice the superheroes!

Skydance CEO & COO David Ellison and Dana Goldberg and Director Alan Taylor Talk TERMINATOR GENISYS

The director and producers talk first cut, deleted scenes, what they learned from friends and family screenings, Easter eggs, and more.

Disney’s 9 Most Wicked Animated Villains

Haleigh, Matt, and Dave single out their picks for best Disney Animated villains, ranging from Snow White's Evil Queen to Hercules' sassy ruler of the Underworld.

New ANT-MAN Trailer Disses the Iron Man Armor

Hank Pym believes that a suit designed to make someone shrink down to the size of an ant isn't “cute technology”.

Page 1 of 4,02712345...102030...Last »
echo ' '; ?>