TIFF 2013: BLOOD TIES Review

     September 6, 2013


There’s no prequel to Blood Ties, but perhaps there should be.  It could provide a reason to give a damn about the characters.  We could see the development of their conflict, the tension between brothers and the brothers’ tension with their lovers.  Instead, Guillaume Canet’s film hits the ground stumbling as the disjointed picture jumps between characters seemingly at random, and never spends enough time to make us care, or wastes time showing just how shallow these horrible people really are.  Coated in the veneer of a throwback crime drama, Blood Ties is an insult to its genre, its cast, and its audience.

Set in Brooklyn in 1974, Frank (Billy Crudup) is a lousy cop whose brother Chris (Clive Owen) is out of prison on a work furlough.  Their relationship resembles roommates more than people who grew up together, and rather than deal with their estrangement, they’re each wrapped up in their own silly problems.  Frank behaves like a stalker to steal back Vanessa (Zoe Saldana) from her reformed boyfriend Anthony (Matthias Schoenaerts), and Chris makes a half-hearted attempt at living a clean life before quickly falling back into old habits and also falling into the pretty and shallow Natalie (Mila Kunis).  Meanwhile, Chris’ old squeeze Monica (Marion Cotillard), who is also a drug-addict prostitute and mother of his two children, is off waiting to become a plot point.

There’s nothing necessarily wrong with dropping us into the middle of an active conflict, but Blood Ties has no idea how to manage it.  Everything feels hollow, contrived, and misplaced.  Vanessa and Frank have a past, but we never see it, and so where we come in, Frank is stalking Vanessa, but eventually she can’t resist his stalky charms.  She leaves Anthony, and also takes away his child while he’s imprisoned.  Vanessa’s behavior hints at a multi-faceted character, but we only see the backstabber.  Likewise, Chris and Monica might have a rich past, but when we meet her, Monica is a sullen, cokehead hooker (Blood Ties does not have the best attitude towards women).


I don’t need to like characters or personally relate to them.  I only need to care, and the film works hard to make us care so little about a cast this good.  I can’t remember the last time I saw so many talented actors completely wasted, but since Canet can’t seem to figure out how to structure his story, no one has a chance to develop.  Frank is almost completely absent during the first half, and Chris is off being a cardboard sociopath who is “CRIMINAL” in big, flashing letters and going through the motions.  By the time the story finally reaches the point where it remembers these two men are brothers and that having one be a cop and the other be a criminal might generate some compelling drama, it’s far too late.

After the screening, I was told that thirty minutes had been cut from the movie following its premiere at Cannes even though the finished feature wasn’t well received at the festival.  Perhaps this cut footage shows the relationships breaking between the characters, but where we come in for this version, the characters are already bitter, spiteful people who are partway through whatever the story demands of them.  Notions of brotherhood and forgiveness are completely superficial (as are Owen and Cotillard’s laughable attempts to do a Brooklyn accent).


Blood Ties operates on presumption rather than presentation.  It presumes that we’ll accept the 70s crime drama candy coating even though Blood Ties doesn’t have a fraction of the power those movies had.  It presumes the cast can carry shoddy characters whose motives are poorly drawn at best.  It presumes the story can operate on the idea of past drama rather than actually showing or selling that drama.  But rather than resting on presumptions, Blood Ties should simply know that pay-off requires set-up.

Rating: F

For all of our TIFF 2013 coverage, click here.  Here are links to all of my TIFF 2013 reviews:

Around The Web

Latest News

ANT-MAN: Evangeline Lilly Announces Marvel’s Micro-Tech Challenge

Girls ages 14 to 18 can win a trip to the 'Ant-Man' premiere by building a project using micro-technology.

LUMBERJANES Getting a Live-Action Movie at 20th Century Fox

Black List scribe Will Widger is set to adapt Shannon Watters, Noelle Stevenson, Grace Ellis and Brooke A. Allen's delightful comic.

HEAVEN KNOWS WHAT Review: Love is a Drug in the Safdie Brothers’ NYC-Set Drama

The Safdie Brothers' narrative follow-up to their great parental drama 'Daddy Longlegs' stars Arielle Holmes and Caleb Landry Jones as heroin addicts scrapping for dope, booze, and shelter in NYC.

New INSIDE OUT Clip Introduces Riley’s Personality Islands

Find out the difference between a standard memory and a core memory.

LOVE LETTERS TO THE DEAD: Catherine Hardwicke in Talks to Direct YA Adaptation

Hardwick will direct the hot YA property from a script by author Ava Dellaira.

SPECTACULAR NOW Director to Helm F. Scott Fitzgerald Tale WEST OF SUNSET

James Ponsoldt will turn his talents from David Foster Wallace to the final years of 'The Great Gatsby' author Fitzgerald's life in Hollywood.

EASY A Director Will Gluck to Helm Disney’s Untitled Lottery Project

The director will also oversee a re-write converting the originally male-led film to a female-centric project.

RESULTS Review: Guy Pearce and Cobie Smulders Shine in Odd Rom-Com Riff

The director of 'Computer Chess' puts a weird spin on the romantic comedy genre to mixed results.

What The Rock’s Been Cooking: A Dwayne Johnson Retrospective

"I'm a pimp. And pimps don't commit suicide."

MAD MAX “Savage Road” Trailer Reveals New Video Game

Valhalla awaits!

Page 1 of 3,97112345...102030...Last »