David O. Russell on Short-List to Direct UNCHARTED: DRAKE’S FORTUNE

     May 3, 2010

David O. Russell’s last film was I Heart Huckabees, an “existential comedy.”  While his next film, The Fighter, is due out in theaters this year, 24 Frames reports that he’s on the shortlist to helm an adaptation of the PlayStation 3 video game Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune.  So to be clear: existential comedy…to adaptation of action-adventure video game.  And yes, O. Russell is also attached to direct Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, but I can’t see that having the price tag of a film like Uncharted and the director’s filmography shows he gravitates to off-kilter stories.  “Off-kilter” is not one of the terms I’d used to describe Uncharted.

For those unfamiliar with the game, Uncharted follows treasure-hunter Nathan Drake (descendant of Sir Francis Drake) and his search to find the lost city of El Dorado.  Some have deemed it “Dude Raider” due to the premise’s similarity to the video game series Tomb Raider.  However, Uncharted has yet to wear out its welcome and the games are well-made and fun (Even the first Tomb Raider games kind of suck).  That’s why it’s a bad idea to make it into a movie.  Hit the jump for my explanation why.

Before, I explain why Uncharted (as well as most video games) shouldn’t be adapted into movies, I will say that O. Russell is at least an interesting choice.  24 Frames compares his consideration to the hiring of Rob Marshall (Chicago) for Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides and Bill Condon (Kinsey) for The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn.  But I think O. Russell is in a different camp from those two directors.  Unlike Marshall and Condon, O. Russell has never had a blockbuster hit or made a film with mainstream appeal.  It’s ballsy of Sony to consider hanging what they want to be a major franchise on his shoulders.  And if I thought adapting the game into a movie was a good idea, I would happily take O. Russell over the assorted hacks who have more experience directing mainstream action flicks.

But they shouldn’t adapt Uncharted or really any modern video game with a heavy reliance on narrative and character.  These games are trying to emulate movies but they add an interactive element.  Uncharted wears its influences on its sleeve as the wise-cracking Drake always has a quip even when scrambling away from a grenade.  He’s Indiana Jones for the gamer crowd mixed with pulp heroes like Doc Savage and action-movie heroes like John McClane.  I just started playing the game and I’d highly recommend it (I’m told Uncharted 2: Among Thieves is even better) due in part to Drake being a fun character who’s well-written and well voice-acted.

But I also like the gameplay.  It’s challenging without being frustrating, simple and addicting, and really takes advantage of the PlayStation 3’s processing power.  A movie would copy the narrative and the characters, but take away the interactive element.  I’m sure you’ve sat down and watched someone play a video game. Is it more fun to watch or to play it yourself?

So if you’re shuddering about the prospect of O. Russell “ruining” the movie of Uncharted, ask yourself why you even want a movie of it in the first place.  Unless you’re Sony or the film’s producers, I don’t think you’ll have a very good reason.

Around The Web

Latest News

3 New ANT-MAN Images Size up Paul Rudd, Michael Doulgas, and Evanelinge Lilly

Marvel’s next film is less than two months away.

9 Movies You Forgot Were Scored by Hans Zimmer

One of the best composers of our time has a resume that's both extensive and versatile, ranging from 'Cool Runnings' to 'Mission: Impossible 2'.

FANTASTIC FOUR International Trailer Brings New Footage; Josh Trank Denies Reshoot Rumors

The director takes to social media to debunk troubled word on the upcoming blockbuster.

More THE MARTIAN Images Feature Matt Damon Surviving Ridley Scott’s Red Planet

The upcoming film also stars Jessica Chastain, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Kristen Wiig, and Jeff Daniels.

DHEEPAN Review | Cannes 2015

Jacques Audiard's latest film won the Palme d'Or at this year's Cannes Film Festival.

Bad Weekend: The Last 10 Memorial Day Movies, Ranked

It turns out most Memorial Day movies aren’t very good.

AMY Review | Cannes 2015

Asif Kapadia's ('Senna') documentary is a biography of sorts, but also an incredible tribute to her as an artist.

Cannes 2015 Winners: Rooney Mara Best Actress, DHEEPAN the Palme d’Or, More

This year's Cannes jury includes Guillermo del Toro, Jake Gyllenhaal, and Sienna Miller, and is headed up by Joel and Ethan Coen. What were their favorites of the fest?

CHRONIC Review | Cannes 2015

Michel Franco’s 'Chronic' stars Tim Roth as a homecare nurse who gets too involved with his patients.

Box Office: TOMORROWLAND Stays Ahead of PITCH PERFECT 2 with $32.1 Million

Disney’s ‘Tomorrowland’ held in first place for the three-day weekend with an estimated $32.1 million. ‘Pitch Perfect 2’ came in second with $30.3 million. ‘Mad Max: Fury Road’ was down 47% in third while the ‘Poltergeist’ reboot opened as expected, in fourth place.

Page 1 of 3,96312345...102030...Last »