Critics You Should Read: Matt Zoller
Seitz
7/13/2005
Posted by Collider Staff
Posted by Mr.
Beaks Ideally, I'd write reviews for both of these films, but, thus
far, neither one has turned up here in Los Angeles. In lieu of my
questionable critical acumen, I'll turn it over to the withering perspective of
Matt Zoller
Seitz, who veers from the heraldic consensus on The World, while making
sweet love to the difficult Tropical Malady, which is finally getting a
stateside release after its polarizing reception at the 2004 Cannes Film
Festival. Some excerpts: "Jia Zhangke's
The World arrives in the U.S. preceded by near-unanimous critical
praise. The more awestruck notices tend to gloss over the movie's flaws;
there are narrative gaps that seem more like evidence of disorganization and
overreaching than conscious, elliptical intent, and Jia sometimes seems
determined to freight even minor scenes with 'importance' by letting them run
as long as possible. (Movies you like are never slow; they're
'deliberate.')" and, on Tropical Malady...
"The film's final confrontation—man facing animal, separated by
great distance and height and enfolded by jungle gloom—is one of the eeriest
visualizations of an unbridgable love in modern
cinema."
|