RSS
 
  February 09, 2012 
 
Collider’s RSS Feed – VERY IMPORTANT
A new Collider is launching...
Review: TERMINATOR SALVATION
Matt can't find the humanity in this war against the machines
You'll Get Your First Look at James Cameron's AVATAR in Front of TRANSFORMERS: REVENGE OF THE FALLEN
But I have my doubts...
Clips from Accidentally on Purpose, NCIS LA, The Good Wife, and Three Rivers
Take an early look at CBS’ fall shows
CBS Announces 2009-2010 Primetime Schedule
The network add four series and moves The Mentalist to Thursdays
The first reviews of Quentin Tarantino's INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
Apparently it's 'too talky'; have these critics seen a Tarantino movie before?
Three Clips from INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS - UPDATED with a 4th Clip
Jew Rats, Interrogating Nazis, and Chatting with a Wounded Diane Kruger
Sam Worthington Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION
He talks about everything – from making Terminator to James Cameron’s Avatar
Christian Bale Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION
He talks about making Terminator, Public Enemies, and how he’s training for his next film
Steven Soderbergh Interview – THE GIRLFRIEND EXPERIENCE
He talks about making Girlfriend Experience and a little bit on Moneyball
Dan Aykroyd Says GHOSTBUSTERS 3 Could Start Filming This Winter
Starting up a 'new generation' of ghostbusters
New Trailer: 9
An awesome-looking animated film that isn't from Pixar
First Look At ABC's FLASH FORWARD and V
Two of the network's upcoming sci-fi drama series
NBC Announces 2009-2010 Primetime Schedule
And Chuck is back…but not until February
ABC UNVEILS 2009-10 PRIMETIME SCHEDULE
V is back
TWILIGHT NEW MOON Teaser Movie Poster
Bella, Edward and Jacob…
 
ENTERTAINMENT REVIEWS
Review: STAR TREK
5/7/2009
Posted by
MattGoldberg
     
 
Written by Matt Goldberg
 

"Star Trek" and "Star Wars" fans have been at war for decades because both have devoted fanbases and both titles have the word "star" in them.  But even after the tragedy of the prequel trilogy, it was still cooler to be a "Star Wars" fan than it was to be a Trekkie.  The masses simply chose to forget the new films and go back to loving the old ones.  But whereas you could still wear a funny "Star Wars" t-shirt and not only get away with it but make the cultural reference and score geek points, "Trek" couldn't manage the cool.  You could wear the rebel insignia or the imperial insignia but try to sporting the Starfleet insignia and either folks wouldn't get it or they would think it was lame.

 

It's clear that there are better "Trek" films ahead and that this re-launch may not achieve the thematic depths some may enjoy but what director J.J. Abrams has done with "Star Trek" is the most practical and perhaps most arduous task in handling this franchise: he's made it cool again.

 

That may seem like a shallow measure and leave some wondering why the film couldn't be deep and hip but Abrams has a mission and it's not boldly going where no one has gone before.  That's putting the nacelles before the saucer.  He has to re-establish the original characters, allow new actors put their stamp on those characters, update the visuals and the universe, connect AND disconnect it to the original series, and, oh yeah, make an exciting summer movie that will have folks arguing over what they loved in the film the most.  J.J. Abrams "Star Trek" is mission accomplished.

 

The plot is breezy and does some narrative gymnastics to establish that this "Trek" exists in an alternate universe.  It's a smart long-term strategy that allows the writers to create new adventures without having to constantly consider the decades-worth of canon established by the television series (both live-action and animated), books, comics, and motion pictures.  But this "Trek" isn't about the plot as much as it's about the characters and that's why I think it works so well. 

 

The focus of "Star Trek" isn't so much the world (although there are enough alien races, planets, and references to go around) but the friendship between James T. Kirk (Chris Pine) and Spock (Zachary Quinto) and moving the rest of the supporting crew of Dr. Leonard "Bones" McCoy (Karl Urban), Nyota Uhura (Zoe Saldana), Hikaru Sulu (John Cho), Pavel Chekov (Anton Yelchin), and Montgomery "Scotty" Scott (Simon Pegg) into place.  This film belongs to Kirk and Spock but the film lets each member of the supporting cast have their moment and when it comes to casting the crew of the U.S.S. Enterprise, they absolutely nailed it.

 

"Trek" does have a few minor problems, the first of which will blind you in the first opening minutes: lens flare.  Yes, J.J. Abrams has seen the future and it is lens flare effect and even Mr. Abrams acknowledges that he went overboard in using it.  The second flaw is the villain, Nero (Eric Bana) who wants to destroy Starfleet because he is evil and Starfleet is good.  With the exception of "The Wrath of Khan", "Trek" has never really been known for its villains and it's a character and a performance not really worthy of Bana's abilities.  Finally, there are a few minor distractions like a cameo by Tyler Perry (WHY.) or a couple references that aren't worth their set-up.

 

But what works in "Star Trek" is absolutely exhilarating.  I have to once again call out the cast for their incredible work.  They've have not only honored these characters but they have started to make their own mark.  With "Trek", Chris Pine is now an A-list movie star and everyone will be scrambling to get him in their movie.  He effortlessly mixes Kirk's ability to charm, rebel, humor, and charm some more.  Even when he takes a brief moment to poke fun at Shatner's iconic pause, the character works. 

 

It's moments like that pause and others where I was amazed at how the film weaved in so many references and made it feel natural.  So often does such fan-service feel forced but with "Star Trek", the references are organic to the action and rarely break the momentum in order to get the appreciative laugh from the audience. 

 

Finally, I have to acclaim composer Michael Giacchino for his amazing score.  His music is loud and constantly attempting to match the size of the spectacle but while some films would use the music as a crutch to deliver the emotions or distract from sub-par effects, Giacchino's score energizes the entire film and it's an even more impressive feat when you consider that it had to exist in the shadow of Jerry Goldsmith's iconic theme.  This new score for "Star Trek" is a must-own.

 

Some Trekkies may look at the new film and wonder "Why?"  Why go out of the way to introduce characters we already know and love but just with different actors?  Why not just go full warp ahead and start telling new stories rather than belabor an origin?  These Trekkies, sadly, do not understand the favor that J.J. Abrams has just done their beloved franchise.  Abrams and his talented cast and crew have brought "Star Trek" back to the mainstream and after this film debuts, the entire world will be more than ready to boldly go where ever the U.S.S. Enterprise wants.

 

Rating ----- B plus

 



 
     
More Collider Entertainment Stories >>>
Collider’s RSS Feed – VERY IMPORTANT

Review: TERMINATOR SALVATION

You'll Get Your First Look at James Cameron's AVATAR in Front of TRANSFORMERS: REVENGE OF THE FALLEN

Clips from Accidentally on Purpose, NCIS LA, The Good Wife, and Three Rivers

CBS Announces 2009-2010 Primetime Schedule

The first reviews of Quentin Tarantino's INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS

Three Clips from INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS - UPDATED with a 4th Clip

Sam Worthington Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION

Christian Bale Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION

Steven Soderbergh Interview – THE GIRLFRIEND EXPERIENCE

Dan Aykroyd Says GHOSTBUSTERS 3 Could Start Filming This Winter

X-MEN ORIGINS: WOLVERINE Uncaged Edition Xbox 360 Review