October 1, 2010


Cheating sumo wrestlers, the value of a name, bribing students to do better in school, and legalized abortion leading to a lower crime rate are all topics in the documentary anthology Freakonomics.  Based on the best-selling book by economist Steven Levitt and journalist Stephen Dubner, Freakonomics takes the book’s individual chapters and hands them off to noted documentary filmmakers Seth Gordon (The King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters), Morgan Spurlock (Super Size Me), Alex Gibney (Taxi to the Dark Side), Eugene Jarecki (Why We Fight), and Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady (Jesus Camp).  While Freakonomics has the makings of an excellent weekly TV show, there’s nothing that holds it together as a complete motion picture beyond the source material and an interesting approach to a particular topic.

Freakonomics is about how “rogue economist” Levitt “explores the hidden side of everything”.  That translates into applying an economist’s perspective to certain touchy subjects such as cheating, crime, or racial divides.  The film tries to put forward a thesis statement about the importance of incentives but it doesn’t look like all the filmmakers got the memo.  While the value of incentives is seen in why sumo wrestlers cheat (Gibney’s segment) and why high school students are willing to get higher grades in exchange for cash prizes (Ewing and Grady’s segment), it’s difficult to see how incentives are a factor in why black names are different from white names (Spurlock’s segment) or why the legalization of abortion reduced the crime rate in the 1990s (Jarecki’s segment).  Perhaps better chapters to take from the book would’ve been “Why Do Drug Dealers Still Live with Their Moms?” and “What Makes a Perfect Parent?”


But taken individually, each segment is highly entertaining.  Freakonomics is an easy and fascinating read, and if you want to see parts of the book effectively visualized, then the movie has got you covered.  Gibney’s segment on sumo wrestling is particularly well done and feels like it could be expanded into its own movie.  Unfortunately, with six different documentarians, you have six distinct voices and the tone of the overall film feels scattered as a result.  For example, Gordon’s introductory and transitional segments feel lighthearted and fun while Gibney and Jarecki’s segments are dark and gritty.

Freakonomics adds up to less than the sum of its parts.  Each segment, taken on its own, is entertaining, informative, and captivating.  But when put together, it’s hard to know why these chapters were chosen for adaptation for any reason beyond the filmmaker’s preference.  Ultimately, I was left wondering if perhaps it would have been better if Levitt and Dubner had teamed with a single documentary filmmaker to pursue an entirely new case file.  I would have settled for a well-documented hidden side of one thing than a scattershot exploration of the hidden side of everything.

Rating: C+


Around The Web

Latest News

HOT PURSUIT: Sofia Vergara and Reese Witherspoon on Making a Female-Led Comedy

The co-stars talk about their new road trip comedy, how to break into the film business as a woman, the challenges of physical comedy and more.

Joss Whedon, Kevin Feige and AVENGERS: AGE OF ULTRON Cast Reveal Memorable Moments from Filming

Whedon reveals the scene that made him go, "I just made a comic book."

THE INFINITE HORIZON: Greg Berlanti to Produce Comic Adaptation for Warner Bros.

Gerry Duggan's 'The Odyssey'-inspired graphic novel is getting a film adaptation from the producer behind 'Arrow' and 'The Flash'.

Atlanta Readers: Win Passes to See MAD MAX: FURY ROAD

This screening belongs to the mad.

SPIDER-MAN Director: Marvel and Sony Considering WARM BODIES, PITCH PERFECT Helmers

A new shortlist gives us an idea of the kind of filmmaker Sony and Marvel want to craft the new Spidey, but what happened to Drew Goddard?

Marvel Needs to Defeat Its Villain Problem

The age of poorly written bad guys should come to a close.


I think we're going to have to start calling this 'Avengers: Civil War'.

New to Blu-ray: SELMA, GOODFELLAS, LOST RIVER, and More

This week's new releases also include a handful of older Spielberg films and a Collector's Edition of 'Mad Max'.

THE COLLIDER PODCAST: Episode 3 – 2015 Summer Movie Preview

Matt and Adam discuss the summer's biggest upcoming films.

MR. HOLMES: New Trailer Features Ian McKellan and Plenty of Sleuthing

The upcoming drama will arrive in theaters July 17th.

Page 1 of 3,93312345...102030...Last »