Hans Zimmer Talks MAN OF STEEL, How He Crafted the Score, Dealing with the Pressure of Following John Williams, Nolan’s INTERSTELLAR, RUSH, and More

by     Posted 321 days ago

hans-zimmer-man-of-steel-slice

I think we can all agree Hans Zimmer is one of the best composers in Hollywood.  If you look over his incredible thirty-year resume on IMDb, you’ll see a wide variety of amazing work across every genre.  However, while he’s done fantastic work over his entire career, his score for Zack Snyder‘s Man of Steel is easily one of my favorites.  Like every great piece of music, it helps tell the story and makes you feel for the characters you’re watching.  Trust me, after you’ve  seen Man of Steel, you’ll be buying the soundtrack.

At the recent Los Angeles press day, I landed an extended interview with Zimmer.  During our wide ranging conversation he talked about his love for John Williams and how nervous he was to tackle Superman, he tells a great story about how he got involved with the project in the first place, he talks about his writing process, which piece of music he struggled with the most, some of the great people that he collaborated with on the soundtrack, and more.  In addition, he reveals he’s writing the score for Christopher Nolan‘s Interstellar, talks about his work on Ron Howard‘s Rush, and shows us around the Eastwood Scoring Stage on the WB lot.  Hit the jump to either read or watch the interview.

Here’s the video.  However, the studio was dark so the lighting isn’t ideal.  The full transcript is below.

hans-zimmerCollider:  Let me start by saying congratulations.  I really mean it when I say that you nailed the score on this.

ZIMMER:  Thank you.

I’ve been a huge fan of your work for a while.  Superman for me is a very big part, I’m a huge Superman fan.

ZIMMER:  How do you think I feel?  Hang on, I got the double whammy, I got… there’s no more masterful composer than John Williams.  Let’s just declare the truth here: there is nobody better than John.  One of his best scores, of course, was the original Superman film.  Secondly, I grew up with Superman.  Superman is in my DNA.  I don’t want to be the one responsible for ruining it for future generations.  There was some procrastination that happened at first.

I have a lot of questions for you, the first being: you’ve done some fantastic scores.  When you were first approached for Man of Steel, was there any hesitation?  How long did it take you to say, “Hey, I think I’m going to do this?”

ZIMMER:  It’s like a whole comedy of errors how this whole thing came about.  I knew Chris [Nolan] was muddling around with an idea with David S. Goyer, and Zack [Snyder] was going to do it, and this was during Inception time.  We had just finished Inception, and we had some party with lots of journalists and loud disco blaring and this journalist asked me if I was going to go do Man of Steel.  I said, “Absolutely not!”  Because, number one, I’m never that presumptuous.  I’ve never met Zack Snyder and he’s obviously an artist with an autonomous point of view, and he probably has a composer that he wants to work with.  Secondly, it’s just too daunting a task.  Come the next day, she completely misunderstood, or wanted to misunderstand every word, every internet comic book blog says “Hans Zimmer’s doing Man of Steel.”  I phoned Zack — “Can someone get me Zack’s number?” — to basically say I’m sorry, I didn’t say this. This is really embarrassing and really presumptuous.  He goes, “Oh, it’s great you’re phoning because I’m listening to some of your music and I really rather like it.  Can we talk about it?”  I went, “Well, I don’t think I’m your guy.  I’ve still got The Dark Knight Rises ahead of me, etc.”  But we did meet, and I didn’t read the script.  I said to Zack I didn’t want to read the script, let’s just meet.  Let’s see if we get on.  We instantly got on, and we have too many things in common.  We’re far too similar not to get on.  I said to him, “Tell me the story.”  He started telling me the story, and I realized this is not the Superman movie that I, one, imagined. 

Man-of-Steel-Henry-Cavill-imageNumber two, he was talking about certain things that were sort of resonating in me.  If he had asked John, John would have written a completely different score as well.  This is a very different movie.  Then came the whole thing, I was completely overwhelmed, number one, by the iconic nature of it, and number two, John Williams cast a huge and daunting shadow through his brilliance.  There was a period of procrastination, plus I had Dark Knight Rises going on, and I kept saying to Chris, “Guys, don’t even talk to me about another movie with the world ‘man’ in it until we finish this one.”  Foolishly there came a moment where I said I’m finished, and within fifteen minutes, it wasn’t even an afternoon, there was the phone call.  “Get to work!”  The only struggle was me. The only person who kept saving me from me was Zack.  All my demons, like everybody’s, every artist has those; you don’t want to be compared.  You cannot compare yourself to anybody because you’ll always end up on the losing side of things.  It just became this thing of do honest work.  Look at the movie.  Serve the movie.  Forget anything that’s happened before.  We’re doing our autonomous Man of Steel, I still call it Superman. 

The tone is so different.  Once I had a hook about what I wanted to write about which I think was very different than what John’s original idea was.  I wanted to write about humble things, about little things.  I wanted to write about the people who never get celebrated.  You know, the farmers in Kansas, the people who are just decent and honest, who leave their doors unlocked.  The people who invite a stranger in without questioning.  All those people who never make the news.  All those people that aren’t celebrities, who don’t need a big sound.  I wanted their cue to on an old upright piano and it was an old upright piano.  I’m not a great keyboard player, I’ve played it, and it could have been better.  Every time I got someone who was a really pianist and played it, it lost all its quirkiness and heart. 

Man-of-Steel-Henry-Cavill-imageOnline right now, over the last month or two, as music has been slowly getting released from the soundtrack, I’ve seen on many websites, my own included, everyone posting clips and being so enthusiastic about the music.  Have you paid attention to all that, and seen the positive reaction online to the score?

ZIMMER:  Yes, I have.  Paranoia is my middle name.  Neurosis and paranoia.  That third trailer, which made people go, “Oh, hang on a second.  This isn’t just an action movie.  This might be something else.  This might actually have some heart in it.”  It uses my theme, but it’s my theme cut to those images, it’s sort of the theme inverted.  I’m really worried that people are going to get so used to that theme that isn’t quite the theme, that when they see the movie they go, “How is that the theme?  That’s not the theme I love!”  It’s slightly different.  The tone is there. 

The third trailer, I can tell you, based on reading online and just talking to people, Warner Bros. has sold this movie in an incredible way.  Also because the movie’s fucking awesome.  Let’s start with that, so it’s easier to sell something when you have great visuals, great music, great action, but more importantly, great characters and great writers.  You have it.  About the writing process on this one compared to the other projects you’ve done, how long was your writing process on this?  Was it more abbreviated?  Was it the typical length?

ZIMMER:  It was abbreviated because I just wouldn’t get started.  All I kept thinking about — American icon, I’m going to ruin it for everybody.  I had ideas.  I had a palette, I had ideas, I knew what I wanted to write about.  It’s just the fear of committing to the first few notes because it’s sort of forever.  I kept thinking, you only get to do a Superman movie once in your lifetime.  There was an artificial importance, being a fan, which came with it.  One day Zack phoned and said, “Have you got anything yet?”  I’m going, “Uh, uh, uh, I can describe it as little post-its you might be able to put on a fridge and some piano noodles.”  And he goes, “Oh, I love piano noodles,” and he says, “You know what, I’m going to come down.”  He came down, and I had the theme that was in the trailer, and it was literally me playing it live right in front of him, making mistakes and stuff.  He’s a decent human being.  He wasn’t going, “Oh my God, this is a disaster!”  Because the whole point about it is it’s so simple.  It’s unbelievably simple.  There’s no great artfulness, there’s no great orchestration flying around, there’s no great whatever.  It’s really, really, really, really simple.  He’s going, “This is great, we’re off to a good start.” 

man-of-steel-superman-henry-cavillSomewhere in this conversation he said, and this wasn’t in any way putting his movie down, he said, “Hans, it’s just another movie.”  That was really liberating.  Part of what I think a great director does, and I think he and Chris are fantastic at that, they figure how to direct me.  He never told me what to write, and he was just endlessly encouraging.  For instance, the scene where Krypton explodes — I don’t think it’s giving anything away, we all know that — the idea was huge, epic orchestral, because that’s what the images are, and I suddenly thought what if we go the other way.  What if we stay focused on Mom.  What is that?  To save the world, to save your child, to give your child away, to send your child across the universe.  What must you be feeling?  I went for the smallest, just a single violin, middle e stradivarious, but that violin going for the epicness, we kept focusing in on the small, the personal.  I try to just keep my eye on that, don’t ever let go of that, don’t ever let go of the characters.  Quite honestly my way into this movie, having grown up with Superman and knowing that Kyrptonite can kill him, I never thought about what else could kill him.  I finally figured it out, it’s very simple: he has feelings.  You can break his heart.  That’s his vulnerability.  He’s a decent man, or Kryptonian.  This idea of wanting to be a part of the human race, that struggle that people have go through.

One hundred percent.  What was the one piece of music in the movie that you struggled with the most?  The one that you rewrote and rewrote and rewrote and were never exactly happy?

ZIMMER: I’m absolutely happy with it now, the Clark Kent piano thing.  Those few notes, I don’t even know how many I did.  I kept doodling around with it, so much so that my music editor, who I hope sees this, said to me, “I hope we can get through one meeting without having to listen to the new Clark Kent theme.”  I knew what I wanted to say, I just didn’t know how.  It’s this weird thing.  I just came off Dark Knight Rises, and I was at my most darkest and whatever, and now you have to get this other under your fingers.  You have to develop the language, you have to spend hours procrastinating and talking to the director about all sorts of things.  The great thing about Zack is he’s a doodler, he draws.  As he’s talking, the image starts forming in front of your eyes, which is pretty much how I work.  Sitting around and I play.  We’re trying to hunt down that thing in our languages, and words aren’t it. 

RUSSELL CROWE as Jor-El in MAN OF STEELThe thing I realized a long time ago, the luxury I have, is I get the next movie lined up.  Your question is which one didn’t work out so well.  There’s always bits left over, ideas left over, and the cool thing is to go and do another movie.  You can start using those ideas.  The way I work, it’s like a diary.  I start off by writing really all the themes and all the orchestration, the sonic palette, and I try to create this world.  I come in that day, see how far I can get that day.  I don’t revise what I did the day before.  Actually on the soundtrack album, on the bonus disc — and for you internet folks we have this rather really cool app called Z+ and it’s literally like my experiments.  There are a few things that are very different about this score, it’s stuff I started to explore during Inception.  Rather than just releasing a soundtrack album, I released an app.  The app was an interactive thing which really self-scoring your dreams, which thought was far and away.  We did something for Dark Knight.  One thing that’s always bothered me?  I can’t listen to my soundtrack albums.  I can’t stand it, because they’re in stereo and my world is a surround world.  This movie, I think you noticed, they were using the surround quite heavily.  So I got together with DTS, they have this headphone x technology which allows you to hear actually 11.1 surround in stereo headphones.  That’s basically the stereo version, and if you put it through the app, it’ll work on Android or the iPhone, you get the full surround sound experience with your cheap and cheerful headphones.  Finally I’ll listen to it.

Actually, what have you recorded in this room?  If you don’t mind.  I don’t know if you remember that I interviewed you in your studio a couple years ago, so it must have gone well.

ZIMMER:  Yes, or else you wouldn’t be here!  One of the things I was thinking about was getting the world’s greatest drummers together, which I pretty much did, and putting them in a square and basically have the audience in the middle of this.  We did some pretty extraordinary stuff with people like Jason Bonham and Sheila E. and Pharrell Williams came out, I can go on.

man-of-steel-laurence-fishburne-amy-adamsThose are some big names.

ZIMMER:  And people who hit things hard.  There is so nothing wrong with 24 timpani going off at the same time.  The other rather odd idea I had, because part of what I kept seeing in my head when Zack was talking about the movie is the endlessness, the endlessness of the fields, the endlessness of the Midwest, the telephone wires, and what would that sound like, the wind in the telephone wires that go on beyond the horizon.  I thought, oh pedal steel guitars, which everybody always thinks is country western, but nobody actually put eight pedal steel players into a room and got them to play basically orchestral music.  It was sort of exciting because these guys all knew each other, but they would never be in the same room together.  These sort of experiments — all of the horrible things you could say about Hollywood, one of the things it’s very good for is it commissions good music for other people to play on a daily basis, and it really drives technology forward.  Like the DTS thing was sort of a no-brainer, let’s just go try this out.  If you think about the consequences of it, when you’re looking to add a movie on computer, you’re only hearing it in stereo.  Now you can actually go and give you your movie in a 5.1 environment headphones.

I’m curious about this room specifically.  We’re at Warner Bros. right now.

ZIMMER:  We’re on the Eastwood Scoring Stage.  You can see it’s sort of set up for somebody’s session that’ll happen tomorrow.

A lot of people don’t get to see the behind-the-scenes inside a room like this.

ZIMMER:  Yes, which to me is an odd thing because I’m so used to these environments.  This a large bit of real estate.  Instead of it being turned into offices and being around for musicians, it’s called the Eastwood Scoring Stage because Clint [Eastwood] really saved it.  He wouldn’t let be torn down and turned into whatever.

man-of-steel-posterYou’ve worked in here a lot then.

ZIMMER:  I’ve worked in here a lot, I’ve worked in Sony a lot, I’ve worked at Fox a lot, and I work in London a lot.  It felt really important that this score was recorded — this is Man of Steel, this is Superman, it had to be recorded in America. 

So you did a lot in this room?

ZIMMER:  We did a whole orchestra in here.

I’ve seen a few behind-the-scenes stuff and I think it was this floor I was seeing.

ZIMMER:  Actually, this floor is a little too shiny right now.  When the floor gets really dull, the sound doesn’t reflect up into the ceiling, it goes right to the microphones.

Oh, I didn’t think about that.  I have to wrap with you in about a second.  Of course I have to ask you have you already started the conversations with Mr. Nolan for a certain sci-fi movie [Interstellar] he might be doing?

ZIMMER:  It’s a longer answer, but put it that way, I wrote something, and he’s been writing, so yes.  We have started.

That’s awesome to hear.  What can you tease people about The Lone Ranger and Rush?

ZIMMER:  Rush is phenomenal.  I love Rush.  It’s just brilliant writing, it’s… let me give you the really short version.  Who would have thought Ron Howard is one of the coolest, most young filmmakers around?  There’s an energy in it, there’s a style in it, it’s brilliant.  Lone Ranger, I finished yesterday.  So I’m still reeling from it.  It’s my friend Gore Verbinski.  I have absolutely no perspective on it other than it’s an honorable and honest piece of work.  There are the comic books, and there are the Westerns, and those are what I grew up with.  It’s a magnificent movie.

Click here for all our Man of Steel coverage which includes interviews, posters, clips, images, and much more.




Please Like Collider on Facebook

Comments:

FB Comments

  • Chris Parker

    Frosty – it’s refreshing to watch an interviewer ask interesting questions and talk about all the things that the fans would want to know. Thank you for rising above the generic throwaway questions and get to the core of the person you’re interviewing!

  • Grayden

    Krypton does in fact explode. Even though it’s always been a part of the canon, we actually haven’t gotten any confirmation one way or another on whether it happens in this movie. Until now.

    • Chris Parker

      Yeah that was pretty spoilery – plus a certain comment Zimmer made about a character during that sequence…

    • Voltron

      The prequel MOS comic that was attached to the Wal-Mart tickets showed Krypton exploding, so I think one can argue that it was already confirmed before this interview.

  • James

    Thanks so much for this interview!

    I love how you let him speak too Frosty. As an interviewer you never disappoint.

  • justkiddingnobutseriously

    Thank you so much for posting this. Hans is the best.

  • http://tarek-to-verso.over-blog.com/‎ tarek

    Great interview.

    I loved when Hans acknowledges how great is John Williams.

  • Alex Hajna

    I think the filmmakers — Goyer, Snyder, and Nolan — have created a world for Superman that is relevant to today’s expectations of blockbuster movies, and can resonate with the society of the 21st century. They have done that — a task that many thought would never be possible to achieve — and they’ve done it perfectly. And in doing that, they’ve helped Hans Zimmer greatly. They created this world where people aren’t going to miss John Williams’ brilliant score. It’s a contemporary Superman, and the music needs to be contemporary, and imitating (or using directly) John Williams’ music would feel out of place.

    That’s not to say Zimmer doesn’t deserve any credit for nailing it. He deserves all the credit he’s ever going to get, and more. I always say, he’s this generation’s John Williams. He knows how to create music that superlatively, and perfectly, matches — and enhances — the mood, tone, and themes of the film itself. He encapsulates the movie in his scores. He is, in every sense of the word, a genius of his craft.

    • There’s A Storm Coming

      Has there ever been a film more headed toward an Epic hype train derailment than Man of Steel? It’s going to fail so severely I almost feel bad for how badly I’m going to ridicule the fanboys. Almost. There’s a storm coming Nolanites and when it hits you’re all going to wonder how you thought you could tout mediocre films for so long and ridicule the rest of us.

      [Chanting]: Screw, Screw Nolan Nolan. Screw, Screw Nolan Nolan.

      Bruce “I’m a puss” Wayne: What are they saying?

      Hackneyed, Cliche Old wiseman in Prison Character: “Screw Nolan”.

      • Alex Hajna

        You’re so funny and clever.

      • There’s A Storm Coming

        Also, does anybody know if there is a Chris Nolan impersonator who’ll come to my house, gather my family in the living room, drop his pants and start pissing in my open mouth while yelling “ACTION”? I’d really like that, in fact, i’m pretty sure that it’ll be the best birthday ever! I’m willing to pay $300 cash. $350 if he can make it taste like asparagus.

      • Public Service Announcement

        Warning: the preceding comment was posted by wanted sex maniac and spokesperson for pedophilia Jonathan Nolan. He and his brother Chris are attempting to lure fanboys into their layer to abuse them anally. Do not respond to these comments.

        Also, the Nolan bros have pledged any profit they receive from The Man of Steel to NAMBLA. You have been warned

  • Joe

    Guys, goto screenrant and watch the latest Nokia exclusive MoS trailer. Gosh!
    You get a full scale of epic with Zimmer’s composition on this film working in concert with the massively grand visuals.

    edit: nvm. I just saw it posted here. have been watching it non-stop. it’s that epic.

  • Calderon

    I know I will be in the minority here, but I’m not the biggest fan of his work. A lot his action-adventure/superhero themes do not really resonate with me the same way John Williams or Elmer Bernstein’s scores resonate with me – a lot of Zimmer’s work lacks depth. Much of his action work is just loud brass, monotonous strings, and pronounced percussion and bass frequencies. From a purely musical standpoint, the themes to a lot of action-adventure/superhero movies in the 2000s that he scored are not that complex: it has taken John Williams years as an orchestrator/amanuensis and years studying at Julliard to achieve a talent of subtlety and depth to his work.

    Call me old-fashioned, but I prefer my film scores with a 70-piece orchestra. I’m not opposing Zimmer using a lot of synthesizers to craft his work, but then again, just as there are people who prefer film over digital and 2-D over 3-D, there will be people who prefer a time of older film scores, with 70-piece orchestras. Personally, Zimmer’s best work is for animation, which does use more orchestral tones for greater effect (i.e. The Simpsons Movie, Kung Fu Panda 2, Megamind).

    • Matt Clayton

      I think Zimmer’s live-action scoring peaked in 2006-2007 with The Da Vinci Code and Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. I was especially surprised at how harmonic and lush the latter sounded in places.

      I otherwise agree. Zimmer’s allowed to do more with animation… and he deserved that Oscar for The Lion King. Pure magnificence.

      • Calderon

        The Da Vinci Code (and for that matter, Angels and Demons) were actually pretty nifty – pretty suspenseful and moving, particularly the ending scene of The Da Vinci Code and the antimatter vial scene in Angels and Demons.

    • Prometheus

      I can understand you not liking Zimmer’s music; it’s not as universally appreciated as, say, John Williams’. However, I don’t think it’s fair to accuse him of simplicity. What his music lacks in obvious complexity is more than made up for by its subtle depth and its ability to invoke more raw feelings. Thematically, one has to agree, his music is quite simple, yet it is his remarkable ability to build complexity upon this simplicity – while retaining the simple, emotionally relevant core – that makes him such a brilliant composer. Take, for example, his work on the Dark Knight trilogy. The entire score of all three movies is based on a two-note motif (the d-f), but this does not make it inherently simplistic. Remember Beethoven’s Fifth!

      I can also accept your preference for traditional orchestration – for hundreds of years all music (including much of the best music ever written) had to use traditional instruments. But now we have the capability to use synthesized sounds that are interesting and unique. Is it not right to utilize these sounds to create new-sounding music? Synthesizers become especially relevant when one realizes that many of the movies he scores are based in very modern times, when technology has become so linked with society. It makes sense then to integrate this technology into music in order to remain relevant.

      On a completely different note, I’d recommend the Sherlock Holmes soundtracks (if, of course, you haven’t already listened to them). They are often more musically complex (in a traditional sense) than his recent scores, and the orchestration is – while not exactly classical – at least largely devoid of synthesizers.

      • Calderon

        I wholeheartedly agree with your standpoint. I liked Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy and Sherlock Holmes – the soundtracks worked in context of the movies. Some tracks/themes, such as “Why So Serious?” (the music that plays during the bank robbery in The Dark Knight) aren’t listenable on an iPod. Others, like “Discombobulate” from Sherlock Holmes, more so – reportedly, Zimmer used The Dark Knight as a temp score, but then got a lot of inspiration from Romani music.

        As a classically trained musician, I’m always a huge fan of lush orchestration, but that’s my take/systematic bias.

      • Prometheus

        I’d disagree with one thing; I think that “Why So Serious?” is absolutely listenable on an iPod (and I do listen to it).

      • Calderon

        “Why So Serious?” is essentially a small ensemble of (electric) strings, feedback from amp, and percussion. In context of the movie, it establishes the Joker and his schemes as an anarchic, capricious punk (Zimmer took influence from Kraftwerk) before his mask is taken off during the bank robbery. When I’m just listening to it with no movie, it just sounds like Hans could have done more with a string and percussion ensemble, like what Bela Bartok did with Music for Strings, Percussion, and Celesta (not a film scorer – he’s a classical composer).

      • Prometheus

        Personally, I don’t appreciate the Music for Strings, Percussion, and Celesta very much. Certainly not as much as “Why So Serious?” I feel like Zimmer is able to create a better emotional effect than Bartok, though this might just be because I haven’t developed much of a liking for Bartok.

    • mani fold

      Very strange no one has mentioned his classic Gladiator score? The Black Rain theme, ‘Injection’ from Mission Impossible 2, The Thin Red Line, ‘Thunderbird’ from Thelma and Louise, Rain Man theme, Beach Song from True Romance (which I know was a cover), ‘Dawn’ from Days of thunder’, etc….?!?! Instead you’re talking about The Simpsons movie and Kung Fu Panda 2? Very odd…

  • ikkf

    It just shows how much Hans is a fan of the character too. Can’t wait.

  • MIXTER

    I like his main score to MOS, but the other incidental music is just not tickling me right now. Too Dark Knight ish. Hope theres bits of the score that we havent heard yet that will resonate more. Was hoping for a more “God like” uplifting tone as is the main theme. Williams nailed it, especially his chilling Krypton theme.
    Maybe it will all come together with the full movie.

  • Pingback: Set photos reveal epic fight scenes in X-Men and Captain America 2! | Musings of a Mild Mannered Man

  • Pingback: The Soundtracks Thread - Page 12

  • DemiathDoomhammer

    Steve’s interviews is the main reason why Collider is the #1 site when it comes to superhero-comic-book-movie-news! keep up the good work, guys! you’re the best!

  • PeteB

    What do you guys think of my fan website dedicated to Interstellar… http://www.interstellar2014-movie.com

  • Pingback: Weekly Film Music Roundup (June 14, 2013) | Film Music Reporter

  • Pingback: MAN OF STEEL Featurette Showcases Hans Zimmer’s Percussion Sessions for the Score | Collider

  • Pingback: MAN OF STEEL Featurette Focuses on Hans Zimmer’s Score and Violin Solo | Collider

Copyright ©2005 - 2014. All Rights Reserved. Built by topLingo

Click Here