Sundance 2011: IN A BETTER WORLD Review

by     Posted 3 years, 81 days ago

in-a-better-world-movie-image-slice-01

What does it mean to set an example?  Can a show of great violence stop further violence?  Can a show of great peace cause peace?  Susanne Bier’s In a Better World explores these questions but it never manages to find their dramatic weight.  The film features some gorgeous cinematography, interesting characters, and solid performances, but they never coalesce into a compelling story.  The narrative has trouble finding its pace as it jumps between various characters and their struggles, but never builds much tension.  At its best, it’s a cold, meditative drama and at its worst, it comes off like The Adventures of Young Punisher.

Christian (William Jøhnk Nielsen) and Elias (Markus Rygaard) are two boys living in Denmark.  Both boys are outsiders dealing with their own strife.  Christian is originally from London, but has recently moved to Denmark since the recent death of his mother.  Elias is a Swede who is constantly bullied because of his ethnicity (I didn’t know that Danes hated Swedes!) and his dental retainer which earns him the name of “rat-face”.  The story also focuses on Elias’ father Anton (Mikael Persbrandt), a doctor who works in an impoverished African village that is being plagued by a ruthless warlord who gets his kicks from cutting up pregnant women.

in-a-better-world-movie-image-01

Christian attempts to protect Elias from a bully only to get a basketball to the face for his troubles.  The next day, the bully is once again hounding Elias but Christian comes to the rescue by beating the crap out of the bully with a bicycle pump and then breaking out a knife and threatening to slit the bully’s throat.  Christian’s philosophy is that if you hit back hard enough, you won’t have to fight any more.  Bier is careful to make sure that although Christian’s actions throughout the film become increasingly violent, we know that he’s not a psychopath.  He’s an angry young boy who wrongly blames his mother’s death on his father.  He wants to control the world again and he thinks he can do that by making jerks pay for their transgressions.

At the opposite end of the spectrum is Anton.  He believes that passivity is the best way to deal with the evils of the world.  He thinks that by not fighting back, he is above the fray and has truly won the battle.  Bizarrely, the film tests Anton’s beliefs but never Christian’s.  Furthermore, Elias is never really torn between the two sides.  He simply drifts around Christian and provides witness to his new friend’s unsettling attitude.  The narrative becomes even more strained as we witness the martial problems between Anton and his wife Marianne (Trine Dyrholm) and the helplessness of Christian’s father, Claus (Ulrich Thomsen).  Bier attempts to provide a richness to the narrative by supplying all these character arcs, but it spreads the story too thin and makes the pacing feels haphazard.

in-a-better-world-movie-image-02

There’s no egregious error in the film.  The performances are fine, there are some gorgeous wide shots, and the story raises some interesting moral questions.  But it never finds the emotional pulse it needs even though it looks for it in Christian’s relationship with his father, Anton’s relationship with Marianne, and the friendship between the boys.  In a Better World has some good ideas that never take off because it keeps missing the emotional core of the characters and their relationships.

Rating: C

For all of our coverage of the 2011 Sundance Film Festival, click here. Also, here are links to all of my Sundance reviews so far:




Please Like Collider on Facebook

Comments:

FB Comments

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention IN A BETTER WORLD Review -- Topsy.com

  • Claus Westh

    To some extent you must have been asleep watching this movie…… As this is one of the best I have ever seen where kids carries are the leading actors. And to some extent you are not right in your analysis. The story is compelling and the jumps from character to character is underpinning a subtle transparency of morality from adult to child.

    The bullying scenes are so realistic that they took me back to the school yard and Elias character is played so splendidly portraying the fear and the shame that follows mobbing. I rarely get misty eyes in the movie theatre, I wept in this case. Maybe because I know this from inside.

    Elias is not Swede and the conflict originates from mirroring his fathers morality, that is insufficient to cope with the real challenges that Elias fights with. And the father finds the same inadequacy in his life and even cheats on his wife facing a divorce. Dull morality and selfcenteredness creates a bad role model. Elias is then lost between his parents egocentric conflicts and with no support he becomes an easy victim. Alone he doesn’t know the how to cope against the atrocities that he experience at school. No he bends his head and choose to be a victim and that is dangerous when one solution is turning the other cheek.

    Change happens when both of them rise to the occasion and actually do achieve something by abandoning their defeatist morality and act upon their feelings of right and wrong…… That is a great moment of transformation. One that makes them full. But they needed a catalyst to start this development.

    Elias befriends a boy full of anger after the death of his mother. Again the morality of the parents are transparent in the child, but this kicks out to the other more dark side and becomes a dangerous cocktail in the friendship with Elias. The friendship catalyse change in both of the boys and blending the dark and the white, the characters become whole and find meaning. It is a very good example of reaching out to get help if you are powerless and not being able to see that can destroy you.

    That is poetic and subtle told by Susanne Bier. Great art if you ask me. Maybe not to North Americans

  • Pingback: THE GUARD Review

  • Pingback: بخشش یا انتقام؟ « حرفه، معمار

  • Pingback: » بخشش یا انتقام؟ حرفه، معمار

Copyright ©2005 - 2014. All Rights Reserved. Built by topLingo

Click Here