ROOM 237 Review

     March 29, 2013


[This is a re-post of my review from the 2012 Sundance Film Festival.  Room 237 opens today in limited release and is also available on VOD.]

Stanley Kubrick‘s The Shining is about characters who are drawn into madness by their surroundings. Rodney Ascher‘s Room 237 is about film critics who are drawn into madness by The Shining. Films that offer up numerous interpretations are like crack to film critics. Movies that are so broad that any interpretation is valid are like bad crack, but a film like The Shining, a film helmed by a notoriously meticulous director and filled with unexplained mysteries and symbolism, is the best kind of film critic crack there is. Room 237 is both a celebration and pointed critique of film criticism. The movie shows how people can think big and expand their minds by thinking deeply and passionately. It also shows how our minds can run away from us and how we’ll twist a movie apart in order to fit our theory rather, and fail to realize that our argument is crazier than Jack Torrance.

Room 237 moves through nine chapters. The first chapter introduces the five different critics who will be providing their theories throughout the film. The critics are never seen, which helps us focus on their words, and also keeps us locked in the constant flow of footage from The Shining, Kubrick’s other works, and non-Kubrick films. After the first chapter, Ascher divides up the film into aspects that critics notice such as the production design, the framing, peculiar moments, and how it all ties together. According to the critics interviewed, The Shining could be about American violence towards Native Americans, the Holocaust, or how Kubrick subtlety revealed that he directed the “faked footage of the moon landing.”  Woven into these arguments are fascinating points like the impossible layout of the Overlook Hotel and rather stupid arguments like using numerology to point out the importance of the number “42”.


One of the film’s greatest flaws is a good one to have: it makes you want to leave in the middle of the picture and go watch The Shining along with all of Kubrick’s other movies. Deep critical analysis of a Kubrick film is completely warranted because of the director’s obsessive attention to detail. It’s tough to argue that anything in a Kubrick film was done by accident. However, because Kubrick is known for his meticulousness, it opens up the door to every critic who wants to look at every detail and build an argument. And even that isn’t good enough as critics begin to use their imagination to see things that have the rest of us scratching our heads. One of the film’s critics argues that Kubrick airbrushed himself into the clouds that are seen at the beginning of the movie.

Ascher knows that these theories can get out of control. It’s hilarious when one critic begins an attempt to prove that The Shining is Kubrick’s secret confession about filming the fake moon landing. The critic prefaces his theory by saying, “I’m not saying that we didn’t go to the moon. I’m just saying that the footage was faked.” And then he starts pointing out Danny’s Apollo 11 shirt, the fact that the moon is roughly 237,000 miles from Earth, and (my personal favorite) he notes that the 237 room key reads “Room No. 237″ “There’s only two words you can spell,” notes the critic, “‘Room’…and ‘moon.'” After the screening, I overheard someone say, “You can also spell ‘moron.'”


But Ascher doesn’t dismiss all of the theories. The numerology guy gets a little out of control with his Holocaust theory (he says “42” pops up because it’s a reference to 1942), but when you combine the Holocaust theory with another critic’s theory about the injustice towards Native Americans, you start seeing the possibility that Kubrick is exploring a history of violence. The Overlook Hotel is built on blood. The Torrance family isn’t the hotel’s first victim. They’re just the latest in a long line dating back to who knows when. Room 237 shows that we can’t develop our own theories if we’re not willing to hear what others have to say. Without critics at least willing to push forward a theory and attempt to provide a justification, then we’re stuck with consumer reviews*.

Room 237 absolutely believes that some viewpoints are valid like when it shows the shifting architecture of the Overlook (such as Danny riding his tricycle on the first floor, turning a corner, and then he’s on the second floor). It takes some obsession to find it, but when you do, it adds more to the experience because there’s a new dimension to both the horror and the character of the Overlook Hotel. There are moments where Ascher needlessly repeats his point (one chapter is devoted to a minor character that’s built up by critics into a significant figure), but he also gives his film a lot of personality and makes it not just a bland, academic analysis on the state of modern criticism. You don’t need to be a movie critic to enjoy Room 237. You just need to be a movie lover. Also, having seen The Shining at least once wouldn’t hurt.

Rating: A-


*And I know I do a lot of those. I’m fascinated by structure but I also evaluate movies piecemeal. Some films I can suss out a subtext and some films are Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time.

Around The Web

Latest News

Disney’s 9 Most Wicked Animated Villains

Haleigh, Matt, and Dave single out their picks for best Disney Animated villains, ranging from Snow White's Evil Queen to Hercules' sassy ruler of the Underworld.

New ANT-MAN Trailer Disses the Iron Man Armor

Hank Pym believes that a suit designed to make someone shrink down to the size of an ant isn't “cute technology”.

Matt Bomer on MAGIC MIKE XXL, the WHITE COLLAR Ending, Shane Black, and More

The actor discusses his adoration for 'Kiss Kiss Bang Bang's Gay Perry, working with Black on 'The Nice Guys', and how 'E.T.' made a strong impression on him as a child.

SELF/LESS: Four Clips & Behind-the-Scenes Footage Reveal the Side Effects of Death

The new 'Self/less' clips finally show off some of Tarsem's signature flair.

New PRIDE AND PREJUDICE AND ZOMBIES Images Prepare for Proper Slaying

Director Burr Steers says his spin on Austen’s novel won’t be winking at the camera.

DEADPOOL: The Merc with a Mouth and Negasonic Teenage Warhead Catch a Cab

A new image showcases Wade Wilson and his young, telepathic pal.


Matt and Adam discuss Pixar's latest and greatest.

Joe Manganiello on MAGIC MIKE XXL, a 3D Sequel, Bodyguarding for Tyrese, and More

The actor discusses his past as a bodyguard for Tyrese, the possibility of 'Magic Mike 3D' and setting a sequel overseas, and more.

INDEPENDENCE DAY: RESURGENCE: Celebrate July 4th President Whitmore-Style

Think you can outdo Bill Pullman? Now you can give the speech yourself using Dubsmash.

Mark Wahlberg, Ronda Rousey Team for Peter Berg Actioner MILE 22

'The Raid' actor Iko Uwais also stars in the Indonesia-set action film.

Page 1 of 4,02612345...102030...Last »
echo ' '; ?>