Shudder's Creepshow just received its Season 2 renewal, but the entirety of Season 1 has yet to premiere. That'll change tonight, Halloween night, as the Season 1 finale airs both on demand and on the Shudder TV live-stream at 9:00 pm ET/6:00 pm PT. We couldn't wait for our Halloween treat. We went ahead and watched the Season 1 finale, which features two segments that are some of the creepiest and crawliest on the show to date: There's the Paul Dini & Stephen Langford-scripted "Skincrawlers" as well as the Joe Hill short story adaptation "“By the Silver Water of Lake Champlain."

But where do they rank among the 12 total segments? That's what we've got for you below, a subjective rundown of the spine-tingling stories in order from least-to-most nerve-wracking. Make no mistake, there's something to love in each and everyone one of these segments, be it the practical effects work on display, the incredible production value, or watching some of your favorite actors hamming it up. They're all delights in the halls of horror; some are just better than others. Some spoilers will follow.

Shudder is available on all of your favorite devices and platforms, including Apple TV Channels. Nicotero’s Oscar, BAFTA and Emmy award-winning Make-up Effects studio KNB EFX GROUP will again serve as creature creators in Season 2.

Shudder’s ​Creepshow is produced by the Cartel with Monster Agency Productions, Taurus Entertainment, and Striker Entertainment: Stan Spry, Jeff Holland, and Eric Woods are executive producers for the Cartel; Greg Nicotero and Brian Witten are executive producers for Monster Agency Productions; Robert Dudelson, James Dudelson and Jordan Kizwani are executive producers for Taurus Entertainment; Russell Binder is executive producer and Marc Mostman co-executive producer for Striker Entertainment.

“Lydia Layne’s Better Half”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Written by: John Harrison, story by John Harrison & Greg Nicotero

Directed by: Roxanne Benjamin

Cast: Tricia Helfer, Danielle Lyn, Michael Scialabba, Jordan Patrick

When Lydia accidentally kills her lover and needs to hide the evidence, she gets trapped in an elevator with the body. The temperature rises and Lydia begins to wonder: will she survive until rescue comes, or will she join her dead lover in hell?

While I love the premise of this one, there's just not enough going on here to keep the tension up and it undercuts on the creepy factor. Helfer and Lyn do their damnedest to sell the shifting power dynamics in their fraught relationship (even after death) but the pacing in this short segment just feels off. Props to the props team, however, for delivering a unique (and satisfyingly squelchy) murder weapon and one of the most realistic severed heads we've seen in some time.

“Gray Matter”

giancarlo-esposito-tobin-bell-creepshow
Image via Shudder

Story by: Stephen King, adapted by Byron Willinger and Philip de Blasi

Directed by: Greg Nicotero

Cast: Adrienne Barbeau, Giancarlo Esposito, and Tobin Bell

After the death of a loved one, a drinking habit becomes insatiable.

Creepshow chose to launch the series with this segment--and it's the one I happened to be on set for--which sounds solid on the surface, but ultimately falls flat. The talent assembled behind and in front of the camera here is great, the story is straightforward, and the set dressing and creature effects are superb. It's just that it rushes through the character's relationships so fast that we never get a sense of this storm-lashed small town and their place within it, so by the time we get to the big reveal, it gives a little gasp instead of a shock to the system. (But there are oh so many Stephen King Easter eggs hidden away in that set...)

“The House of the Head”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Written by: Josh Malerman (Bird Box)

Directed by: John Harrison

Cast: Cailey Fleming

Dolls are Evie’s favorite companions, but when a severed toy head appears in her dollhouse, Evie can no longer protect them.

I actually liked the second segment of the series' opener better than the first, but your mileage may vary. The creepiness really came through thanks to the disturbing head that appears in an otherwise wholesome child's dollhouse. Things get increasingly dire throughout the story's run, giving it perhaps the best pacing of the lot, but she never fesses up to her parents about just what is going on within the little house. That's fine; it's a classic horror trope that ratchets up tension and frustration in the audience. But though the head itself eventually made its way into the wider world, there was no extra gut punch to bring the miniature horror out in a bigger way, and that's a missed opportunity.

“All Hallows Eve”

creepshow
Image via Shudder

Written by: Bruce Jones

Directed by: John Harrison

Cast: Connor Christie, Madison Thompson, Jasun Jabbar, Andrew Eakle, Michael May, Julia Denton, Scott Daniel Johnson, Tom Olson, Erica Frene

Even then they’re a little too old, this group of friends still want to trick-or-treat but getting candy isn’t all they are looking for.

Here's a great segment that's fit for the kiddos. It felt like a throwback to Are You Afraid of the Dark? or Goosebumps, mostly because it centers on a group of kids semi-terrorizing a neighborhood on Halloween. The only issue here is that they give away the hook a bit too early. There's a mystery at the center of this friendship group and it's one you can kind of figure out before too long. Still, it's a solid story that ends with a one-two punch of a great practical effects reveal and, for once, a somewhat happy ending.

“The Companion”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Written by: Matt Venne, based on the short story by Joe R. Lansdale, Kasey Lansdale & Keith Lansdale

Directed by: David Bruckner

Cast: Logan Allen, Afemo Omilami, Carey Jones, Voltaire Council, Dylan Gage, Addison Hershey

One night, Harry stumbles upon an old scarecrow. But when he accidentally brings the scarecrow to life and finds a dead body in its wake, can he fix everything before he becomes the scarecrow's next victim?

If you've dabbled in such scarecrow stories as R.L. Stine's "The Scarecrow Walks at Midnight" from his "Goosebumps" series or Alvin Schwartz's "Harold" from "Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark", then you pretty much know what you're getting from this Lansdale Family story. Not that there's anything wrong with that. It's just that the short runtime for this segment robs us of getting to really know the main character beyond his experiences of being bullied at home. Cut in a flashback explainer that's almost as long as the main story itself and things start to get a little messy. But the reason "The Companion" ranks this high is due to the super-creepy practical effects work and the fact that we'd love our own spooky skeleton monster to do our bidding.

“Night of the Paw”

creepshow-night-of-the-paw-bruce-davison
Image via Shudder

Written by: John Esposito

Directed by: John Harrison

Cast: Bruce Davison, Hannah Barefoot, Susannah Devereux, Grace Toso, Ryan Clay Gwaltney

A mortician saves the life of a woman who shows up at his door one night, but unbeknownst to her, the man had wished for a murderer to come put him out of his misery... maybe she wasn't so fortunate after all.

Another classic. This one's a twist on the "monkey's paw" tale, about a titular totem that grants three wishes--one for each curled finger--that always come with a price. It's a version of the genie's cautionary tale (which also appears in Creepshow) but this one's elevated by Bruce Davison's excellent performance. This story harkens back to the original tale, which arrived over 115 years ago from W. W. Jacobs, and puts a somewhat modern twist on things. It's creepy, for sure, and it's got some twists that you may see coming but are still enjoyable to watch. But other than Davison's performance, accolades go to the effects for their zombie work; A+ stuff there.

“Times is Tough in Musky Holler”

creepshow-david-arquette-times-is-tough-in-musky-holler
Image via Shudder

Written by: John Skipp and Dori Miller

Directed by: John Harrison

Cast: David Arquette, Dane Rhodes, Karen Strassman, Tommy Kane, Tracey Bonner, Kermit Rolison, Connor Hammond

Former Mayor Lester Barkley is in prison, and with his most loyal supporters locked up too, his odds don't look good. Their gruesome means of control went too far, and now, they’ll be getting a taste of their own medicine—or rather, the dead will be getting a taste of their former mayor.

But even better zombie work comes in this segment. This story goes back to the ol' "vengeful punishment for past dirty deeds" idea; comeuppance, if you will. And the narrative dances between the current events unfolding and the recent past history which reveals that, yep, these people probably deserve whatever's about to happen to them.

Oddly, when you see David Arquette's name, you'd think he'd be the main focus here, but he's not really. He's a bit player to Dane Rhodes unhinged and wonderfully performed usurping mayor and "magic man" of Musky Holler. This segment is perhaps the most original of the bunch and its creature effects deserve a hand (and some arms, legs ... and a face.) And believe me when I say that seeing that room full of suspended chairs on chains in person, now knowing what awaits above, is delightfully disturbing. The way this one ends with a take on good old-fashioned American pie is just delicious.

“The Man in the Suitcase”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Written by: Christopher Buehlman

Directed by: Dave Bruckner (The Ritual)

Cast: Antwan "Big Boi" Patton, Will Kindrachuk, Ravi Naidu, Madison Bailey, Ian Gregg, Nasim Bowlus, Carey Jones

A college student brings the wrong bag home from the airport only to find a pretzeled man trapped inside, afflicted by a strange condition that turns his pain into gold.

Remember that genie story I teased earlier? Here it is. You'd think that people would learn not to be greedy little shits with such stories as these in our culture, but I guess the promise of untold riches is too strong for some to resist. This story combines the cautionary tale of wishes that come with too steep a price to pay with a sort of "Stanford Prison Experiment" that puts the beneficiaries of said wishes in the place of power, and pain. The more they torture the poor trapped djinn, the more money they get. But unbeknownst to them, even if it's knownst to us in the audience, they're playing right into his hands. And they're not the only ones, as is evidenced by the number of suitcases awaiting transport at the segment's end. So while the genie effect may not be the best of the bunch, the unique spin on this story makes it stand out.

“Bad Wolf Down”

creepshow-season-2-release-date-shudder-cast
Image via Shudder

Written by: Rob Schrab

Directed by: Rob Schrab

Cast: Dave MacDonald, Callan Wilson, Kid Cudi, Nelson Bonilla, Jeffrey Combs, Kate Freund

A platoon of American soldiers is forced to hide out in a dilapidated police station during WWII, but they soon discover something more sinister than war has been unleashed inside the building: a werewolf.

This one had us at Jeffrey Combs, but then hooked us even further with Nazis and werewolves. I mean, how can you go wrong? This tightly plotted little WWII story feels like it deserves its own franchise (as does Marko Kloos's similar story "On the Use of Shape-Shifters in Warfare", which was adapted into Netflix's Love, Death & Robots). We not only get to see Combs go all-out as an enraged Nazi leader and father to a murdered (Nazi) son, we get to see a bunch of commandos get the ultimate upgrade via voluntary lycanthropy. It's original, it's gory, and it's great.

“By the Silver Water of Lake Champlain”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Spoilers ahead since this segment comes from the season finale.

Written by: Jason Ciaramella and Joe Hill, story by Joe Hill (from his new collection, Full Throttle)

Directed by: Tom Savini

Cast: Sydney Wease, Connor Jones, David Alexander Kaplan, James Devoti, Gena Shaw

Rose finds Champ, the legendary monster of Lake Champlain. But when her unhinged step-father threatens to take all the credit, Rose realizes Champ may actually still be lurking in the lake, waiting to strike.

Off-screen, this segment has perhaps the most Creepshow pedigree after "Gray Matter." Its story hails from Joe Hill, son of Stephen King and the troublesome child in the first Creepshow movie. It also sees horror icon Tom Savini not only leading the sculpt of lake-monster Champy, but also directing the short. All were expertly handled. This is more than a story about a monster prowling the depths of a small-town lake, it's the story of a monstrous man taking advantage of a wounded family and sowing discord with his every breath. Sure, it may be another comeuppance tale and one that you see coming, but this segment is a great combination of human menace on the part of James Devoti's contemptible Chet and earnest emotions on behalf of the kids, with a dash of monstrous intervention. We believe in Champy.

“The Finger”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Written by: David J. Schow

Directed by: Greg Nicotero

Cast: DJ Qualls, Antwan Mills, Jake Garber

Clark has a passion for found objects. One day, he finds something particularly odd: a finger. He takes it home and it grows- first another finger, then an arm, then a whole creature. Clark names him Bob, and they get along great... until Bob starts murdering.

The best of the bunch, for my dollars, are stories that combine original premises with fantastic creature/practical effects, and bring a dark humor to the proceedings. "The Finger" excels here. DJ Qualls is great as Clark, a put-upon nobody who needs a little help in life. He's a packrat of sorts, a collector. So when one of his collectibles turns out to be not just a creepy severed finger (of our own dear Creepy, in a fantastic lore drop) but a popcorn-eating murder monster, Clark's luck may be on an upswing. "Bob", as he dubs the miniscule murderer, begins to dispatch the people in Clark's life who cause him pain, but like a cat from hell, he brings his kills home with him. That means the viewers are treated to blood-soaked montages of Clark trying to dispose of the evidence (and failing to do so in spectacular fashion). But it also means that Clark is going to be fingered for these murders. Even locked up, he still has faith that Bob will come and rescue him, and so do we.

“Skincrawlers”

creepshow-episodes-ranked
Image via Shudder

Spoilers ahead since this segment comes from the season finale.

Written by: Paul Dini & Stephen Langford

Directed by: Roxanne Benjamin

Cast: Dana Gould, Chad Michael Collins, Hina Kahn, Melissa Saint-Amand, Beth Keener, Jason Graham, Darin Toonder

Dr. Sloan has discovered a miracle cure to weight loss in a rare fat-sucking leech. But during a solar eclipse, an unintended and explosive side effect of the leeches is revealed: they use the patients' bodies as hosts for their eggs... and it’s time to hatch.

Ever so slightly edging out Bob for the best of the bunch is this hilarious tale featuring an unexpected performance from Dana Gould (The Simpsons). Why? Because it does everything "The Finger" does, but ups the ante a tic each time. The premise isn't inherently scary: A weight loss solution that is purported to have instant results and no side effects. The setting isn't one you'd find in a typical horror story: Sunny days at the park, a brightly lit morning news studio, an immaculately clean and precise medical center. And the characters aren't your typical losers with an ax to grind or a grudge to bear. With the exception of Gould's character, who is actually pretty happy with his physicality aside from the occasional dosing of ginkgo biloba pills, everyone in this segment is thin, athletic, and beautiful.

However, most of them have taken advantage of Dr. Sloan's miracle weight-loss cure, including Sloan himself. No pill, no diet, no exercise needed, just a session or two with a fat-sucking leech he discovered in a storm drain. The thing is, the leeches work surprisingly well, but they leave something behind ... something that waits until the right time to strike. And strike it does! In a very bloody sequence that required a literal blood cannon on set to pull off, Gould is vindicated in his decision to skip out on the miracle cure. But he's also forced to face the mistakes of Sloan and his disciples, cleaning up the very bloody mess in the process. It's a nod to Alien, to creature features of yesteryear and today, and it's just a bloody good time for horror fans. This is what Creepshow is all about, and we can't wait to see more.