The Big Picture

• Melanie Lynskey's experience on Two and a Half Men was marred by being undervalued and underpaid, highlighting the gender pay gap in Hollywood.
• She felt trapped in the role and unable to pursue other projects due to the show's success and false promises of future storylines.
• Lynskey had to fight hard to negotiate a new contract that would give her the freedom to leave the show and pursue more fulfilling roles, eventually finding success in projects like Yellowjackets and The Last of Us.

Melanie Lynskey is one of those actors who always pops up in a project and never disappoints. Most recently, the Emmy-nominated actress played the chilling and cutthroat Kathleen on HBO's The Last of Us and currently plays the adult version of Shauna in Showtime's hit series Yellowjackets, alongside Christina Ricci, Juliette Lewis, Tawny Cypress, and Lauren Ambrose. But in the early 2000s, Lynskey was most associated with her Two and a Half Men character Rose, whose storyline saw her soft-spoken and quirky character alternate between being Charlie Harper's (Charlie Sheen) stalker and his love interest during the series. However, what many may not know, is how ugly her departure from the Chuck Lorre creation was. In an interview with Vulture, Lynskey revealed that she did not have the smooth departure she would have hoped for from Two and a Half Men, adding to her many reasons for wanting desperately to leave the show.

'Two and a Half Men' Left Melanie Lynskey Feeling Undervalued and Underpaid

Melanie Lynskey's experience on Two and a Half Men did not get off to a good start. She soon discovered that her pay was far from ideal. In fact, according to SAG (Screen Actors Guild), the show was paying her the lowest fee possible. Considering our awareness surrounding feminist issues in recent years, this is unfortunately not too surprising. The "Time's Up" movement, whilst originally created to address sexual harassment within the entertainment industry, also highlighted the gender pay gap affecting many female actors in Hollywood and beyond, and wider gender-based discrimination in the workplace. Clearly, in 2003 when Lynskey joined the show opposite Sheen and Jon Cryer, her pay was not up to scratch, getting her off to a bad start.

Furthermore, when placed on Two and a Half Men, Lynskey was represented by an agency that did not value her as they should have, or see her true potential. Being cast on the sitcom without much forethought, Lynskey was catapulted into a show without regard for her suitability for the project, or her well-being. As such, she had the disappointing realization when working on the show's first season that this was not the role for her. What had initially seemed like a fun idea and good money had quickly deteriorated into a mismatched part and a bare minimum paycheck.

Melanie Lynskey's 'Two and a Half Men' Contract Was a Nightmare

Alongside the crushing realization that she was not going to enjoy working on this part, Lynskey was also met with the harsh reality that she would not have the freedom to work on other preferred and better-suited projects. When voicing her desire to leave, the success of Two and a Half Men put dampeners on this valid request, with its first season earning it an impressive 9.9 rating. Furthermore, she was promised a range of storylines for her character in the next season — only to hang on long enough to find out that these plot lines were all played out within one sole episode of the second season, keeping her in the show for far longer than would be rewarding to her character.

With a new resolve to pursue other work, Lynskey worked hard to negotiate a new contract. The show tried its best to convince her that this was not going to be the best course of action, and she had to remain confident in her desires and push for the contract that would allow her the freedom she needed. Eventually, after it reportedly took almost a year of discussion, a new contract was drawn up, but only after many delays and much reluctance. Luckily, Lynskey was able to negotiate a contract that allowed her to be able to stay or leave as necessary, freeing her up for the parts she was most passionate about.

It wasn't until Two and a Half Men ended in 2015 that Lynskey was fully freed of her obligation, as up to that point, she had still been appearing in a minimum of one episode per season. This was a long-awaited outcome, and if we reflect and compare this treatment to the way that many famous men have made outrageous demands in various well-known movies and TV shows, we can see just how unjust this is — especially considering the fact that Rose was not one of the most principal characters, nor did the actor start on the best pay. Thus, her story is frustratingly recognizable and was certainly a highly unjust way to exit a show.

Melanie Lynskey’s Shines On Shows Like 'Yellowjackets' and 'The Last of Us'

Despite its success, eventually running for a total of 12 seasons (even continuing after Charlie Sheen's character's death), Two and a Half Men did not finish with rave reviews, ending with a disappointing (and strangely petty) series finale. Arguably, Melanie Lynskey's instincts were right, and despite the trials to get there, her efforts to have more freedom away from the show meant that she could pursue more acclaimed projects. This journey to more exciting projects includes the current thriller-drama TV series Yellowjackets, of which Season 2's premiere has set a streaming record, and as mentioned previously, her eerily calm take on the character of Kathleen in The Last of Us. However, even before this tumultuous foray into better-suited TV shows, Lynskey was acclaimed for her performance in Heavenly Creatures with Kate Winslet. This obvious potential, whilst frustratingly overlooked during her Two and a Half Men era, proves that it is always better to fight for what we deserve in life, professionally or creatively, even if it requires an ugly exit to get there.

Two and a Half Men is available to stream on Peacock in the U.S.

Watch on Peacock