Watch the ‘Toy Story 4’ Filmmakers Discuss Fan Theories on Andy’s Dad, Toy Immortality

     October 8, 2019


Toy Story 4 director Josh Cooley and producer Mark Nielsen discussed a number of fan theories about the entire Toy Story franchise in a new video for Vanity Fair. If you’ve been wondering where the hell Andy’s dad went, you won’t exactly get an answer, but Cooley and Nielsen share their thoughts on what could’ve happened to Andy’s perpetually absent father.

“Witness protection, maybe?” Cooley says.

Nielsen offers, “I’d like to think that maybe they split up? Maybe he’s still alive and living somewhere in another town? Maybe he was part of the CIA and is deep undercover. Any of those are possible, we don’t need to know because it’s really all about serving the story of Woody playing the father figure role in Andy’s life.”


Image via Disney-Pixar

Cooley and Nielsen read through a number of theories submitted by Reddit users covering everything from whether or not Boo from Monsters, Inc. and Bonnie from Toy Story 3 and 4 are the same person, whether the girl who used to own Jesse before abandoning her in Toy Story 2 grew up to be Andy’s mom, and if Home Improvement takes place in the Toy Story universe.

“Maybe that’s who Andy’s dad is,” Cooley suggests. “Tim ‘The Tool Man’ Taylor.”

Things get a little dark when one Reddit user posits the theory that the toys are immortal, and will outlive every human on earth before ultimately inheriting the planet.

“That seems plausible,” Nielsen says. “I kind of buy that.”


Image via Pixar

“One of the things I’ve heard is that maybe the toys are some sort of vampire that instead of sucking blood they suck the joy out of children and live forever,” Cooley laughs. “We never really thought about that when making the movie, it’s more about just family and being friends.”

The filmmakers also explain the ending of Toy Story 4, and why they chose it over two other possible endings that had been written. So if you haven’t seen Toy Story 4 yet, you might want to skip that part of the video, or loudly sing a Randy Newman song to yourself to block out the spoilers. Watch the video below, and check out our review of Toy Story 4.

Latest News